Back in June I created a spreadsheet (original entry
Blood and Bone ipod | updated 2006 spreadsheet) to calculate which MLB division, since 1995, is the best. My brief explanation:
Each division has its own page with the standings for each year, beginning in 1995, along with playoff results. Points were assigned as such: one point for winning percentage x 100 (a .506 divisional percentage in a year gets you 506 points,) 25 points for a wild card berth (every division has a winner, so division titles are meaningless here,) 50 points for a league pennant, and finally 75 points for a world title. Additionally, your playoff record is taken x 10, plus the number of wins x2, so a 5-6 record in the playoffs nets you 55.45 points (5 divided by 11 is your winning percentage of .450, that times 10 is 45 points, plus 5 wins times 2 points is 10 more points. The point is to make the postseason winning percentage valuable, and wins moreso, yet not enough to eclipse the importance of the regular season.)
Updated now with the final regular season and playoff standings, some 2006 trends:
• The AL East is still the dominant division since the 1994 realignment, but finishing last this year for the first time drops the lead in average points from 30 to about 23 over the NL East; the Orioles’ and Rays’ record coupled with a 1-3 playoff record hurt the division. It would take a big swing – like a title by the Mets along with a Phillies or Marlins wild card – but the NL East could conceivably take the top spot next year.
• The NL Central, 5th overall coming into 2006, leapfrogged the NL West into 4th riding the Cardinals’ World Series victory. However, while the trend continued (as it mathematically pretty well must) that the division with the World Champ is the overall winner, it was by far the smallest margin of victory yet. 2000’s AL East outranked the NL East by only 76 points, and the NL Central this year crushed
that record by only besting the AL Central by a paltry 22 Beowulf & Grendel download points. Having an 83-win champion while your opponent carries a wild card and a pennant will do that to you. By the way, the average spread between number one and number two coming into 2006 was 110, the highest being 161 by the Marlin-led NL East over the AL East (one of two years, along with 2001, that the second place division didn’t play home to the World Series runner-up.)
• The total for the NL Central, 682, was also easily the lowest for the reigning division, besting the old mark (708 by the 2000 NL East.) Another mark of MLB parity: the AL East’s last place finish came with the third-highest points ever for the cellar dweller, and the smallest margin between first and last place ever. Parity, mark three: over the last six years, each of the divisions has won a world title once and only once.
• In the ten years prior to 2004, the two Central divisions had claimed just two of the twenty top two positions. In the two years that have followed, they’ve occupied four of four. Last year the AL Central saw its first world title, and 2006 gave the division its first wild card, the last division to claim one. The Cards’ tenth world championship was the first ever for the NL Central division.
• The Cardinals won the World Series.



